Monday, April 4, 2011

Anus

I watched "Stoute Boudjies" because I had to. Let's leave it at that.



I approached the film with trepidation, as I usually avoid Willie Esterhuizen's movies due to their lower-than-lowest-common-denominator approach to comedy. The closest I usually get to this type of comedy is "Bakgat", which by comparison looks like Von Trier's latest filmic bombast. On a previous effort, "Poena is Koning", a friend commented how it's not just the sexism that's bad in his movies; it's also the blatant racism and fattism that get you. "Stoute Boudjies" features rampant sexism, as well as fattism (guess who's the perpetual loser?) and racism. (If an actor of colour willingly participates in a film like this for a paycheck, what do we do with the notion of racism?)

Some background: Esterhuizen was a successful showman who was responsible for two favourite Afrikaans sitcoms, "Orkney Snork Nie" (Woepsie-wapsie!) and later the lesser but still successful "Vetkoetpaleis". Nothing he's done since has reached the level of popularity that those shows obtained in the 1990s. As for his film work, it was his "Lipstiek Dipstiek" in the mid 1990s that made sex part of popular braaivleis discourse. It was OK to talk about genitals now, since it's funny; Seff Effrica would never be the same again. Given how conservative most of South African entertainment was until 1994, Esterhuizen did break some new ground, even if it was limited to how much naked flesh you could get away with on screen. It was "Last Tango in Joburg" for the Afrikaans adult comedy crowd, but without sophistication.

Afrikaans isn't a world language, and the lighter-skinned group of people who speak it constitutes a minority in South Africa. Yet some Afrikaans filmmakers, Esterhuizen among them, choose to give local audiences comedies that are vulgar for vulgarity's sake alone, regardless of the stereotypes perpetuated for the sake of a cheap laugh. Why marginalise a minority in this way, showing them to be incapable of nearly  everything, including sexual activity? Certainly, it seems as if many of the stereotypes and cliches are lifted from equally bad American teen comedies, but those seldom look as inept and on-the-fly as this film.

I got the following plot synopsis from the Nu Metro website:

HARDUS, is a third year computer sciences student who lives in Johannesburg with his divorcee mother, Madelet (played by Dorette Nel). Hardus has to find work for the varsity holiday to earn his keep, but at his age, he is more interested in losing his virginity than finding a job. "Madelet" rhymes with "slet", Afrikaans for "slut". I guess it's funny.

His best friend and comrade in arms, VAATJIE VISAGIE, played by Gerhard Odendaal, does little to help in the virginity stakes, but does provide an opportunity to work as a washer at Mr. De Vries's bakery. Mr. De Vries (played by actor Matt Stern) sends them on an errand that proves to be much more adventurous that any of them could have imagined. Here, Vaatjie (from "Vaatjies Sien Sy Gat") is an obesity-stereotype, while Matt Stern's De Vries is an effeminate annoyance. 

PETRO, played by the stunning Angelique Pretorius, (a former FHM model of the year) impacts hugely on Hardus's life. He not only finds himself totally besotted with her but when they end up in bed together, Hardus's world, gets turned upside down.
This is mainly because Petro's boyfriend, Harley Davidson biker OS, (played by macho man Asley Saunders), wants to break Hardus's neck for screwing his chick. The fact that she no longer happens to be his girl, does not deter OS from wanting to cause some grievous bodily harm to Hardus.

The film is a hilarious teen sex comedy
[it is not "hilarious" unless you're OS's mental cohort], targeted specifically for the young Afrikaans movie going audience [they must think we're idiots]. It is contemporary and truthful version of life in post world cup South Africa [yes, if "contemporary" means "recently released" and "truthful" means "as rubbish as most other teen sexcoms"; I do not see the relevance of the SWC reference]. 

"Stoute Boudjies" makes for depressing viewing. Between the wisecracks and ass-cracks, the film demonstrates there is a place somewhere underneath the bottom of the barrel.

Friday, March 25, 2011

A disease is a disease by any other name

Khomotso Manyaka (Chandra)

South African cinema seems to be going through a period of, well, good filmmaking. (I'm not including marginal releases that fall under the 'kommin Afrikaner' designation, as we'll never get rid of those.) After the highly entertaining and polished "Jerusalema" (Ziman 2008), here's the somber yet gentle story of a country ravaged by HIV/Aids: "Life, Above All" by Oliver Schmitz. Note the punctuation. This is the film that Schmitz, in spite of directing the seminal 1980s gangster drama "Mapantsula", could not initially get local funding for, and that eventually enjoyed a 10 minute standing ovation at the 2010 Cannes Film Festival. (European backers financed the film until the local DTI kicked in. Which begs the question: to what an extent is "Life, Above All" a South African film? That's a discussion for another time.)

I suppose it's understandable that "Life, Above All" would have trouble obtaining financing, and also that it would be much loved at Cannes. Regarding the first matter, here's a film that condemns not merely the disease but the South African (and I use the term broadly) tendency to not talk about HIV/Aids; if you pretend that it doesn't exist, it might go away, or at least spare everyone the embarrassment of acknowledging that a loved one had died because of the disease. To what an extent did former president Mbeki help to create this view? Could it be that the film was seen as possibly too dangerous to fund locally, as if local financiers could not commit to the project on an ideological basis?

Regarding the latter matter: for all its severity, the film is never message-heavy (or heavy handed). Schmitz, working from Allan Stratton's novel, views the social effects of HIV/Aids through the eyes of young Chandra (Khomotso Manyaka), a  young girl who finds her life shaped by the disease and her community's approach to it from the opening shot. The film follows her attempts to salvage what she can of her collapsing family.

Like "The 400 Blows" (Truffaut 1959) and "Come and See" (Klimov 1985), the film's use of the child's perspective seems to make us more receptive to its themes, and speaking for myself, more open to its emotional appeal. While the child's view makes some events more palatable and plays more directly to emotions, you are still regularly reminded that you're viewing life through the eyes of someone who is not supposed to be dealing with what Chandra faces on a daily basis. The film has a stunning opening shot and suggests a contextual expectation for Chandra that, a few moments later, is utterly subverted. It's one of the most effective scenes in the whole film as Chandra's unfortunate position in her own family is brutally highlighted. How this single scene speaks to something very common in South Africa haunts the rest of the film as we are made to understand that Chandra is supposed to represent numerous nameless girls who find themselves in similar positions.

Chandra's journey is captivating as the film moves effortlessly from one event to the next, surely in no small part due to Manyaka's earnest presence. For most of its running time, the film works very well on technical and narrative levels. The film is not without potential pitfalls; I have not yet made up my mind about the exact lack of dimension that accompanies some secondary characters: the promiscuous friend; the drunk father; the uber-judgmental community members. While the film's ending works story-wise, it fails emotionally since the payoff requires us to buy into something specific that I for one was not entirely convinced of. After the relative harshness of everything that had come before, the ending felt like a let-down, a too-tidy, audience friendly packaging of the problem. The message is spelled out, not suggested. A neat finale is the last thing you need when you're dealing with children and HIV/Aids.