Friday, March 11, 2011

Put down that shotgun, Rory!

Hey mister!
Breck Eisner's "The Crazies" represents one of my favourite types of movie: the American-small-town-gone-batshit-due-to-disease-or-collective-psychopathology thriller. American cinema often paints its rural areas as filled with homegrown saints and weed-whackin' good folk ("Sweet Home Alabama", "Runaway Bride") and it's always refreshing to see the apocalyptic potential in those locales. Surely, when some sort of apocalypse hits America, it will start in a small town? In "Eight Legged Freaks", giant spiders terrorised a town, itself a riff on the ground-burrowing cattle-guzzlers in the classic "Tremors". A recent entry into this subgenre, Frank Darabont's "The Mist", contrasted the threat of the danger lurking in the mist with the equally devastating human evil.

In  "The Crazies", a remake of George A. Romero's 1973 cult favourite, small town sheriff David (Timothy Olyphant, so great in "Deadwood", so wasted in "Hitman") and his deputy Russell (Joe Anderson) find their quaint town, Ogden Marsh, turning on itself as townfolk start acting crazy. Crazy in this sense means "homicidal" and "fueled by intense bloodlust". David's wife Judy (Radha Mitchell), the local doctor, also becomes involved in the events which compels David to take action like he couldn't even conceive of before.

Eisner's film does nothing new, really; bad mad people run amok, good sane people must survive. Of course, and surely this is not a spoiler, the military gets involved somehow, and the ending comes as no surprise. In this type of film, predictability is not by default a negative quality. It's a highly competent thriller filled with much gore and brutality and a few special moments which had me petrified. Admittedly, what one considers scary or frightening is as patently subjective as what one considers funny. The film isn't meant to be "The Descent". Unfortunately, Eisner relies on musical cues for scares too much, which lessens the film's overall impact. As is to be expected the make-up in this kind of film has to be state of the art, and it is; every open wound glistens.

What to make of "The Crazies" thematically? Is it trying to educate us about military interventionism, and how it messes things up instead of smoothing them out? How military assistance is sometimes worse than their absence? If that's the case, the film hearkens back to a key theme of 1950s and 1960s American SF. Indeed, insofar as the film presents the military (re)action in this film, especially their solution to the problems in Ogden Marsh, it is clear that they are as much part of the destruction around them as whatever is making the townsfolk go ballistic. 

"The Crazies" is limited in its commentary, though, and is refreshingly unselfconscious (for a film of its nature) about the type of film it is. There are no in-jokes, no cameos by zombie authorities (as far as I know). This is a serious thriller - how 'thriller' differs from 'horror' is another discussion - like Shyamalan's eco-snooze "The Happening" was. The difference is that "The Crazies" does not take itself as seriously as that film, and is all the better for it.

It goes without saying the "The Crazies", with its superficial social pessimism and its oodles of gore, is not for everybody. Still, if you appreciate the use of the standard issue pitchfork for purposes related to madness and mayhem, look no further for your fix.

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Return of Undead Man and the Incredible Catatonic Girlfriend

Dialogue sample #1: 
Edward: “I know the consequences of the choice you’re making. I’ve lived through it, and to let you suffer that… You believe I have a soul, and I don’t. But to risk yours, just for the sake of never having to lose you, it's the most selfish thing I’ll ever do.”
Bella: "I thought that you were afraid that I'd be too different. Like I wouldn't be...warm, I wouldn't smell the same."
Edward: "You'll always be my Bella. My Bella, just less fragile."
(http://twilightsaga.wikia.com)

Dialogue sample #2:
Inga: "Werewolf!"
Dr. Frankenstein: "Werewolf?"
Igor: "There."
Dr. Frankenstein: "What?"
Igor: "There, wolf. There, castle."
(www.imdb.com) 

The first dialogue sample is from the third "Twilight" film, the dramatic "Eclipse". The second is from Mel Brooks' hilarious comedy "Young Frankenstein!" from 1973. Both samples make me smile. The difference is that the latter sample is intentionally funny, while the former is supposed to be profound, where "profound" means "indulgent" and "oh-so-sincere". In the context of the film, these spoken words sound hollow and campy, more so than anything in a cult comedy by Brooks, who would later deliver the sporadically funny "Dracula - Dead and Loving It".

Certainly it's not the dialogue that gets audiences to flock to the cinema. I do not deny that the "Twilight" films speak to a specific younger demographic; the box-office is a good indication of this. Consider, however, that the IMDb scores of the three "Twilight" movies, as ranked by users, are 5.5/10, 4.5/10 and 4.8/10. Clearly, most people seem to understand that something is amiss with the franchise but, much like "Transformers" fans, it may be that they cling to the hope that "the next one will be worth it".


"Eclipse", although better than its predecessors, is not worth it. It's a ho-hum continuation of a tired love story spun against a backdrop of inter-species conflict that "Underworld" portrayed with greater flair and substance. The biggest complaint I have about the whole series is that the producers have spent three films telling a story that could easily fit into a single 140 minute feature film. Film 1: Edward and Bella fall in love, while Jacob is a friend; Victoria swears to avenge her lover's death. Film 2: Edward leaves Bella and Jacob makes his move; Victoria is somewhere. Film 3: Victoria assembles an army of vampires to attack the Cullens and give her the chance to kill Bella; Jacob and Edward fight nicely over who gets Bella. The end. It's the result of greed and bad writing that a simple three act story is split into three separate parts, prolonging not only Bella's suffering but also mine. How much screen time do you need to tell people that abstinence is good?

David Slade, who previously directed the antithesis to "Twilight" in the graphic novel adaptation "30 Days of Night", makes "Eclipse" the best looking of the three movies. In addition, he actually makes the action scenes come alive at times despite the weightless special effects (the werewolves look like they exist in another dimension, not the one in which the action is taking place). In the end though, lackluster story trumps visual style, and you can only shoot a pining Bella and panicking Edward in so many ways. (There are, apparently, many ways to frame a shirtless Jacob. At least the film mocks its own obsession with the Native American's naked torso. Cultural-bodily exploitation reaches a new low here.)

There is a scene where Bella, freezing her bottom lip off in a tent atop a snowy mountain, understands that the lifeless Edward cannot supply her with some body heat to warm her. Luckily Jacob, who is indeed warm even without his fur coat, offers his body heat much to Edward's initial chagrin. Then there's a moment where the two men grab each other's arms in the heat of this discussion, and for a second, just a second, I thought that vampire and werewolf would reconcile in ways Stephanie Meyer had not imagined. I'm sure it's unintentional but it's a welcome ambiguous character moment in a film where there are very few surprises.

Don't make the mistake of thinking that there's character development in this film, or the series, at all. Character development is not falling in love, sighing, moaning, and glittering in the sun. It's an internal process by which characters reach a point of metamorphosis, even apotheosis. When I hear people talk of how Bella and Edward have "grown", my heart grows heavy. At this point, essentially, all the characters are exactly the way they started out. Bella's relationship with Edward has provided her with nothing but pseudo-existential angst and a lack of any ambition except to be Edward's wife. How depressing is that?