The Coen brothers, Joel and Ethan, have been rather prolific over the past years, maintaining around one new release per year. After their "No Country for Old Men" Oscar triumph a few years ago, they've presented audiences with offbeat humor ("Burn After Reading") and existential dilemmas ("A Serious Man"), all filtered through eccentric eyes. Coen films are easily identifiable by their unpredictability, unconventional protagonists (The Dude stands chief among them) and off-beat dialogue.
In light of the above, I'm a bit taken aback by all the comments stating how their latest film, the Western remake "True Grit", which features the above elements, is their most audience friendly and straightforward work. If "straightforward" here means that one thing leads to another in the film, then yes, it is straightforward. But sometimes it seems as if "straightforward" is meant to mean "simple" or "plain", and that is patently incorrect. Along with these statements are implications of how their film is a conventional, if well written, embodiment of recognisable genre iconography.
Bah. I never thought that one could make a Coen movie sound "conventional" but that's what some people would have one believe. Actually, "True Grit" is another 'clearly Coen' film; the brothers have taken stock characters and a vengeance-based plot and turned it into something profound. Mattie Ross (Hailee Steinfeld, who commands this film front and center) is a fourteen year-old girl looking for her father's killer, a man she believes goes by the name of Tom Chaney (a greasy Josh Brolin). She has the will but not the way to get him herself, and so she employs (though that may not be the best word to describe this transaction) a US marshal called Rooster Cogburn (a character made famous by John Wayne and immortalised by Jeff Bridges). They are sometimes aided in their quest by Laboeuf (Matt Damon), a Texas Ranger who's been on Chaney's track for some time and looks forward to apprehending him. (Steinfeld and Bridges are superb.)
Looking at the above plot description, the film does sound "straightforward", so let's get the "straightforward" qualities out of the way. There are landscape shots captured by legendary Roger Deakins. There's a shoot-out. Men are tested by the elements, their own internal weaknesses and by their companions, with whom they nearly inevitably butt heads. However, there is more to the film than those genre indicators. For instance, the landscape shots only appear some time into film, and are not used as an initial establishing device as most Westerns use it. And the action, when it happens, is always bound to the points of view of key characters, and in one instance the action is brutal and abrupt.
There is what one might call "character development" for one character, while another completely subverts the notion. In addition, there is a scene where Mattie and Rooster expect a familiar face to appear, and when this does not happen and they face instead someone that seems half animal, Rooster's reply is priceless. This moment - with the character's placing in the middle of the frame instead of somewhat to the side - is pure Coen ingenuity.
"True Grit" thematically addresses the idea of doing what has to be done, doing the right thing, sometimes against great odds and at great cost. Still, as the opening and closing shots make clear, "True Grit" isn't just a Western with outlaws, lawmen and beans around the fire. It is a celebration of the genre and trappings. The opening shot seems at first to be a movie frame fluttering into sight and then reveals itself to be a memory from a long time ago. This evokes not only the narrative content that opens the film, but also makes us aware that we are watching a type of movie that went out of fashion a long time ago (at least at the box-office) yet never goes away completely. In a goosebumps inducing final shot, the filmmakers display their love for the genre as much as the movie characters with just enough respect and sentiment.
"True Grit" is the best Western since "Unforgiven" and was nominated for 10 Oscars.
(I thought that "No Country for Old Men", another type of Western, was the best film of 2008, and I listed "A Serious Man" in my top ten of 2010.)
Sunday, February 27, 2011
Monday, February 21, 2011
Old school Spielberg
Once when I was a child, my parents gave me Neil Sinyard's "The Films of Steven Spielberg" for my birthday. At first I looked only at the pictures, particularly those images from Spielberg's big movies: "E.T.", the "Indiana Jones" movies, "Close Encounters of the Third Kind" and so on. I chose to ignore his early movies on account of the practical reason that my local video store did not have them in stock, so why bother? Hence I have not joined Goldie Hawn on the "Sugarland Express" and I still haven't seen Spielberg's take on Columbo.
The early Spielberg movie that would garner the most attention and acclaim over the years would be the thriller "Duel" (1971), a simple cat-and-mouse story based on a Richard Matheson ("I Am Legend") short story published in Playboy.
Filmed as a low budget "movie of the weekend" for the American TV channel ABC - Spielberg was not yet to be trusted with expensive studio fare - the film uses its budgetary limitations to its advantage in pitting a mild-mannered city dweller David Mann (Dennis Weaver) against a malicious (and never seen) truck driver on the open country road, stripping the film of distracting subplots and secondary characters that take up much screen time. We are so aligned with Mann that we are privy to his thoughts as he reflects on his predicament, making it clear that he in his Plymouth really is no much for a redneck in a massive truck. Weaver is completely believable as the panicking Mann (in an interview, Matheson concedes his naming the character Mann as representative of 'man' was "foolish") and clearly anticipates Kurt Russell's Jeff Taylor in "Breakdown" (Mostow 1996) twenty five years later. ("Breakdown", by the way, is one of the 1990's most deserving B-movies and remains worth a watch.)
"Duel" starts with the point-of-view of a car gradually exchanging the city's congested roads for the easy driving of the country. Mann is on a business trip, and we learn that he and his wife had had a falling out the night before which had not been resolved. His telephone conversation with his wife, where we are shown not only the wife but also the couple's children, is the film's most misguided creative choice - why does Spielberg insist on locating Mann in a nuclear family while the character would have been just as convincing without this character baggage? Mann encounters the truck early on as it hinders his way, overtakes it, and in so doing incurs the wrath of whoever drives the truck. The rest of the film consists of Mann being hunted by the truck, with the truck showing up every now and again just as the tension threatens to ebb.
While the film relies too much on musical cues to announce objects and themes (a shrill twiiiiing! when the truck appears around the corner, with some sounds indicating a debt to Hitchcock collaborator Bernard Herrmann), the camera and editing become fittingly frenzied as the film builds up to the inevitable final showdown. ("Duel" is maybe not an accurate title for the film, as Mann is dominated by the truck 99% of the time.) The film is good at demonstrating Mann's fear, as in scenes where Mann finds himself taking a break after a dangerous showdown in a roadside diner. Boxed in by the diner's pink interiors, Mann is shown as positively petrified. Another scene is illustrative of Spielberg's command of tension: Mann is waved down by a bus driver. The bus overheated and now needs a push to get going again. The bus is transporting school children, and the kids are playing on Mann's car and the roadside. We know that it's a matter of time before the truck reappears, and what happens then?
[A digression: in John Carpenter's superb "Assault on Precinct 13" (1976), which is another significant American film from the revolutionary 1970s, a gang member shoots and kills a young girl eating an ice cream. It happens on camera, and comes as such a surprise to someone fed on a diet of safe American filmmaking that you replay the scene just to check that it actually happened. For a second I pondered the possibilities of carnage in the school bus scene, but Spielberg is always protecting children; even if he puts them in harm's way himself, things always work out fine for them.]
I wanted to embed the "Duel" trailer below, but it makes the film look lightweight and absurd and gives far too many of the film's best scenes away.
"Duel" is a road movie thriller that puts similar films (see "Joyride") to shame by showing these more recent, road rage-era incarnations as self-indulgent. I much prefer this film to another famous film about the dangers of having trucks on roads, "The Wages of Fear" (Clouzot 1953).
The early Spielberg movie that would garner the most attention and acclaim over the years would be the thriller "Duel" (1971), a simple cat-and-mouse story based on a Richard Matheson ("I Am Legend") short story published in Playboy.
![]() |
| The impotent protagonist |
"Duel" starts with the point-of-view of a car gradually exchanging the city's congested roads for the easy driving of the country. Mann is on a business trip, and we learn that he and his wife had had a falling out the night before which had not been resolved. His telephone conversation with his wife, where we are shown not only the wife but also the couple's children, is the film's most misguided creative choice - why does Spielberg insist on locating Mann in a nuclear family while the character would have been just as convincing without this character baggage? Mann encounters the truck early on as it hinders his way, overtakes it, and in so doing incurs the wrath of whoever drives the truck. The rest of the film consists of Mann being hunted by the truck, with the truck showing up every now and again just as the tension threatens to ebb.
While the film relies too much on musical cues to announce objects and themes (a shrill twiiiiing! when the truck appears around the corner, with some sounds indicating a debt to Hitchcock collaborator Bernard Herrmann), the camera and editing become fittingly frenzied as the film builds up to the inevitable final showdown. ("Duel" is maybe not an accurate title for the film, as Mann is dominated by the truck 99% of the time.) The film is good at demonstrating Mann's fear, as in scenes where Mann finds himself taking a break after a dangerous showdown in a roadside diner. Boxed in by the diner's pink interiors, Mann is shown as positively petrified. Another scene is illustrative of Spielberg's command of tension: Mann is waved down by a bus driver. The bus overheated and now needs a push to get going again. The bus is transporting school children, and the kids are playing on Mann's car and the roadside. We know that it's a matter of time before the truck reappears, and what happens then?
[A digression: in John Carpenter's superb "Assault on Precinct 13" (1976), which is another significant American film from the revolutionary 1970s, a gang member shoots and kills a young girl eating an ice cream. It happens on camera, and comes as such a surprise to someone fed on a diet of safe American filmmaking that you replay the scene just to check that it actually happened. For a second I pondered the possibilities of carnage in the school bus scene, but Spielberg is always protecting children; even if he puts them in harm's way himself, things always work out fine for them.]
I wanted to embed the "Duel" trailer below, but it makes the film look lightweight and absurd and gives far too many of the film's best scenes away.
"Duel" is a road movie thriller that puts similar films (see "Joyride") to shame by showing these more recent, road rage-era incarnations as self-indulgent. I much prefer this film to another famous film about the dangers of having trucks on roads, "The Wages of Fear" (Clouzot 1953).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



