While "Pi" (1998) announced Darren Aronofsky as a major new talent, it was "Requiem for a Dream" (2000) that indelibly etched his name into the movie books as one of the new auteurs in American cinema. His latest, "Black Swan", takes the madness and persecution mania of "Pi" and the individualised devastation of "Requiem" and places it in competitive ballet. The result is rather breathtaking.
Nina Sayers (Oscar nominated Natalie Portman) has her heart set on the starring role as the Swan Queen in her company's revival of "Swan Lake". The manipulative Thomas (Vincent Cassel) tells her early on that she is great as the White Swan - pure, untouched - but lacks a certain force and dimension when she attempts to embody the Black Swan - carnal, hungry. It is clear from the very beginning that something is not right in Nina's world, that something is askew. We understand the film's terms: we are joining a potentially mentally unstable young woman on a dark journey. To add further stress to Nina's already surfacing mental fragility, Lily (Mila Kunis) joins the company as a dancer. In addition to this threatening outsider figure, Nina's mother (Barbara Hershey) has controlling means of her own.
"Black Swan" is one of the few films where, from the opening frames, you know you're in for something special. The film opens with a dream sequence, motifs of which effortlessly find their way into Nina's waking life. The story of Swan Lake also becomes a mirror (talking of key motifs) of Nina's own struggle to contain her psyche while trying to let her id out enough to construct a credible performance. Nina's struggles with sexuality, her performance and her over involved mother culminate in a stunning final 20 minutes of precision editing enhanced by Clint Mansell's unsettling score. Aronofsky skillfully toys with perception and subjectivity, using the mirrors to suggest never ending space while the strict confinement of Nina's mother's apartment and her room appear truly claustrophobic.
Much has been said of the comparisons between this film and Aronofsky's previous effort, "The Wrestler" (2008). One should not be quick to force parallels. While "The Wrestler" also dealt with one character's dark journey as complemented by the virtues and vices of others, "Black Swan's" emphasis on psychological spillover and self-destruction results in a more potent motion picture.
Some critics have called the film absurd and deliciously melodramatic (occasionally intending the labels as compliments). While there may be some validity to those descriptions, I think it has more value to refer to the film's style and form as directly corresponding to Nina's increasing instability. Ever since German Expressionism the mind was shown as a fragile thing, and "Black Swan" is a masterful demonstration of that fact. Here is one of the best films of the year.
Tuesday, February 8, 2011
Saturday, February 5, 2011
Faces smeared with dirt
Kirk Douglas leads his men in "Paths of Glory".
The above image occurs not long into Stanley Kubrick's rather intimate anti-war film "Paths of Glory" (1957), and occurs during one of the late director's much loved tracking shots. It's one of the earliest examples of what would become a signature of the director, and a much referenced signature at that (see "Atonement"). I use intimate because, like with Melville's French resistance masterpiece "Army of Shadows", Kubrick's interest is in his protagonists' reactions to the context of warfare, and not just explosions and gunfire, making it rather contained for a war epic.
Kirk Douglas stars as Col. Dax, a principled man trapped in the French war machine during World War One. When told that he and his men need to take the German stronghold called "The Anthill" in less than two days from now, Dax understandably has his doubts. There to make sure that all goes according to plan is the dubious Gen. Mireau (George Macready), who seems to epitomise the hunger for war felt by those who never get into the fighting themselves but prefer to direct it from afar, impeccably dressed and enjoying some tea. As the film progresses, it becomes clear that the tension between Mireau and Dax will come to erupt, and indeed it happens most significantly after the battle is over and the lives of the some French soldiers hang in the balance.
Anti-war films would become something of a habit for Kubrick, whose "Dr. Strangelove" (1964) remains, like "Paths of Glory", a timeless indictment of the absurdity of war and those who manage it. With "Full Metal Jacket" (1987), Kubrick took aim on the dehumanising effect that the Vietnam war had on young American men, and shows us that the dehumanisation started on home ground already. "Paths of Glory" is easily as powerful as these films, and bears the advantage of, like "Dr. Strangelove", coming in at around 90 minutes.
This is far from the indulgences of "Barry Lyndon" and "Eyes Wide Shut", both testing my patience with their adoration of themselves. It's a lean film with the clear aim of breaking down the dominant (at the time) mythology of French heroism (which resulted in many European countries banning the film for many years). Kubrick never shows us the apparent evil, the Germans, because he is concerned with what the 'good guys' were doing to themselves. "Paths of glory" has dated incredibly well because of Kubrick's near timeless visual style, and his focus on character and theme over spectacle.
The film was a testing ground to further develop Kubrick cine-eye. Consider the image below, and see how a master arranges a shot:
Click below to watch a key scene from the film where two soldiers discuss whether death by machine gun or bayonet would be best. Ebert describes the dialogue here as approaching Shakespearean:
The above image occurs not long into Stanley Kubrick's rather intimate anti-war film "Paths of Glory" (1957), and occurs during one of the late director's much loved tracking shots. It's one of the earliest examples of what would become a signature of the director, and a much referenced signature at that (see "Atonement"). I use intimate because, like with Melville's French resistance masterpiece "Army of Shadows", Kubrick's interest is in his protagonists' reactions to the context of warfare, and not just explosions and gunfire, making it rather contained for a war epic.
Kirk Douglas stars as Col. Dax, a principled man trapped in the French war machine during World War One. When told that he and his men need to take the German stronghold called "The Anthill" in less than two days from now, Dax understandably has his doubts. There to make sure that all goes according to plan is the dubious Gen. Mireau (George Macready), who seems to epitomise the hunger for war felt by those who never get into the fighting themselves but prefer to direct it from afar, impeccably dressed and enjoying some tea. As the film progresses, it becomes clear that the tension between Mireau and Dax will come to erupt, and indeed it happens most significantly after the battle is over and the lives of the some French soldiers hang in the balance.
Anti-war films would become something of a habit for Kubrick, whose "Dr. Strangelove" (1964) remains, like "Paths of Glory", a timeless indictment of the absurdity of war and those who manage it. With "Full Metal Jacket" (1987), Kubrick took aim on the dehumanising effect that the Vietnam war had on young American men, and shows us that the dehumanisation started on home ground already. "Paths of Glory" is easily as powerful as these films, and bears the advantage of, like "Dr. Strangelove", coming in at around 90 minutes.
This is far from the indulgences of "Barry Lyndon" and "Eyes Wide Shut", both testing my patience with their adoration of themselves. It's a lean film with the clear aim of breaking down the dominant (at the time) mythology of French heroism (which resulted in many European countries banning the film for many years). Kubrick never shows us the apparent evil, the Germans, because he is concerned with what the 'good guys' were doing to themselves. "Paths of glory" has dated incredibly well because of Kubrick's near timeless visual style, and his focus on character and theme over spectacle.
The film was a testing ground to further develop Kubrick cine-eye. Consider the image below, and see how a master arranges a shot:
Click below to watch a key scene from the film where two soldiers discuss whether death by machine gun or bayonet would be best. Ebert describes the dialogue here as approaching Shakespearean:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



